The High Cost Of Revenue-Based Marketing Fees

There are two ways that most marketing agencies charge for their services:

  1. A fee for a service, where the agency and the client agree to charge a fixed dollar amount for a service
  2. A fee as a percentage of revenue, where the agency takes a slice of the total in exchange for services

At first blush, a fee as a percentage of revenue might sound like a good deal. It ain’t. We explain why below.

How Much Does It Cost To Make Your New Business Grow?

If you have a brand new business, marketing is enormously expensive:

  • New businesses need lots of up-front marketing investment just to get to the point where they can start doing sales
  • Any marketing investment is huge if your company has little or no revenue
  • Even when a new company starts to grow, marketing remains a large expense as a percentage of the total

If someone comes along and offers to do all this expensive work for cheap, that sounds great! But can a marketing agency really deliver all the work you need for a percentage of your small revenue?

And, if this agency was good at what it did, why would they agree to accept a percentage of a small number?

How Much Does It Cost To Market An Established Business?

Let’s say your company does $20 million a year in revenue. What can marketing do for you?

  • Generate leads? You bet.
  • Grow sales? Maybe, assuming the “extra” leads are worked properly by the sales team.
  • Increase profits? Maybe. Profits have to do with more than just increased sales.

What’s the value of more leads that may lead to more sales and – hopefully – more profits? 10% of revenue? Hardly.

The fact is, if you have a $20 million dollar a year company, you can hire experienced marketing staff and retain a good agency for a set amount that’s less than 1% of your revenue.

And experienced staff and a good agency will generate more leads. That’s how they stay employed and/or keep collecting checks.

A Marketing Agency Is Really Going To Invest In Your Future?

Marketing agencies that work for a percentage of revenue often talk about “partnership,” but that’s a lie. All businesses exist to make a profit. If you pay an agency $500 a month for marketing, and they’re profitable, they have to do less than $500 worth of work.

And if you find an agency that’s not profitable, they’re not going to be a good partner. Either they won’t survive, or they’ll take advantage of you later.

New companies need a lot of marketing and advertising work:

  • They need a website
  • They need content for that website
  • They need a pay-per-click advertising strategy
  • They need a social media strategy
  • They need an email strategy
  • and son…

Can you get all of that for 10% of revenue? Or 3%? Of course not.

If some company offers to do these things for pennies on the dollar because of a “partnership,” they’re lying.

Revenue-Based Marketing Fees Are The Exact Opposite Of What Most Companies Need

If you’re a small company, paying a percentage of revenue for marketing is like spitting in the ocean. It has no meaningful impact.

And if you’re a big business coughing up a percentage of sales, why? Your company can afford to pay the best agency and hire the best staff, all of whom will agree to provide a service for a flat fee. Why share profits when you don’t have to??

We’re obviously biased here, but we think fee-for-a-service is the only reasonable way to hire a marketing agency. It’s the only way to spend exactly what marketing is worth. Any other arrangement is either paying too much or not enough.

More Content

Performance-Based Marketing Is Bad For Clients

Performance based marketing is a bad deal.

A recent article from the Think With Google marketing blog included a baffling statistic: 41% of agencies now use a performance-based compensation model. This is…

Read More

Convermax: The Fitment Search Solution For Shopify, BigCommerce, And More

Today, we are speaking with Alex Sherbachev, Founder and CEO of Convermax. Convermax offers on-site search solutions – including Year-Make-Model Fitment Search tools – for…

Read More

Understanding ACES/PIES Data Standards

We don’t say it often enough here at Spork, but if you’re in the business of selling parts and accessories online, you’re in the data…

Read More
Auto parts in the cardbox. Automotive basket shop. Auto parts store.